Issue - meetings
26/01178/FP Morrisons Superstore , Broadway, Letchworth Garden City, Hertfordshire, SG6 3TS
Meeting: 01/10/2026 - Planning Control Committee (Item 71)
REPORT OF THE DEVELOPMENT AND CONSERVATION MANAGER
Installation of CCTV pole cameras and installation of valeting air/vac unit following removal of no.7 parking spaces.
Additional documents:
Decision:
RESOLVED: That application 26/01178/FP be REFUSED planning permission for the following reasons, with delegated authority granted to the Development and Conservation Manager to finalise the reasons for refusal:
A) The proposed CCTV pole cameras and air/vac units would result in an unacceptable adverse intensification and visual impact, appearing out of context and harmful to the locality, failing to comply with the provisions of Policy D1 of the Local Plan and the aims of Policy DP3.1 of the National Planning Policy Framework.
B) The residential amenity if North Herts Environmental Health respond with an objection to the application.
Minutes:
Audio recording – 02 hours 20 minutes 31 seconds
The Principal Planning Officer (Development Management) presented the report in respect of Application 26/01178/FP accompanied by a visual presentation consisting of plans and photographs.
The following Members asked questions:
· Councillor Claire Winchester
· Councillor Emma Fernandes
In response to questions, the Principal Planning Officer (Development Management) advised that:
· Some works had been undertaken before planning permission had been granted.
· Existing CCTV cameras were not for consideration on this application, only the new cameras as outlined in the proposed plans.
· The application had been submitted by Morrisons and the CCTV cameras were to protect the air/vac units that would complement the EV chargers.
The Chair invited the first Public Objector, Ms Nicola Fox to speak against the application. Ms Fox thanked the Chair for the opportunity and provided the Committee with a verbal presentation, and highlighted the following:
· There was concern over the cumulative impact of the commercial infrastructure that would cause an intensification of the industrial character of the site.
· CCTV cameras would violate privacy, and floodlights would light up their garden as per the lighting report.
· The new assessment had not considered the cumulative noise impact of all the proposed development across various applications.
· A response from the Environmental Health Team had still not been received.
· The site had progressively changed over the last 7 years, and this had caused uncertainty and stress, which had affected their mental health.
In response to a point of clarification from Councillor Emma Fernandes, Ms Fox advised that a floodlight had been switched off after the Store Manager had visited their home, as level of their home meant that they saw and heard everything in the adjacent car park.
The Chair thanked Ms Fox for their presentation and invited the second Public Objector, Ms Jackie Sayers, to speak against the application. Ms Sayers thanked the Chair for the opportunity and provided the Committee with a verbal presentation, and highlighted the following:
· A similar application had been refused as seen at paragraph 1.7 of the report and living conditions had worsened for immediate neighbours since the EV charging points had been installed.
· The cumulative industrial intensification of the area would have a major effect, rather than a minor effect as detailed in the report.
· The noise impact assessment had not mentioned all the other noises that would arise from the car park such as car stereos and shouting above noise, and the cumulative effect of all noise should have been accounted for.
· Two applications on this site, which had been refused earlier in the year, had not been detailed in the report and this application should be refused for the same reasons.
· Paragraph 4.3.21 of the report mentioned that the CCTV cameras would face neighbouring dwellings, and the trees that screened them would soon be bare.
· Concerns had been expressed by the Letchworth Garden City Heritage Foundation on the impact to adjacent properties, contrary to the report, which stated that they had made no comments.