Agenda item - NOTICE OF MOTIONS

To consider any motions, due notice of which have been given in accordance with Standing Order 4.8.12.

RESOLVED:

That this Council expresses its concern about the perilous state of the upper reaches of the River Ivel and other local chalk streams, including the Rivers Purwell and Hiz and St Ippolyts Brook.

Council notes that the River Ivel has been continuously dry in an area extending from the Ivel Springs Local Nature Reserve downstream to Radwell for a period of well over a year.

Council further notes that there has been no flow in the upper Ivel during half the months of the previous four years.

The River Ivel is one of the rare and ecologically important chalk streams of the Chiltern Chalk Aquifer. According to the Ivel Springs Greenspace Action Plan for 2010–2015, “Chalk rivers are extremely rare and included in the Herts Biodiversity Action Plan. The river and its wetlands are important habitats for a wide range of species”. This is a resource we should cherish and protect. Instead, the watercourses are dry, the fish are dead and other associated wildlife is gone.

Council is therefore determined to ensure that a healthy year-round water flow be restored and maintained in the upper reaches of the river from the area known as Ivel Springs down to Radwell Lake and beyond.

Furthermore, Council recognises that the disaster of the Ivel is not an isolated instance among the chalk streams of the Chiltern Chalk Aquifer: many others are suffering dangerously low levels and consequent environmental harm.

Council therefore undertakes to implement the following actions:

1. Elicit information from Affinity Water regarding their plans for reducing abstraction rates from the chalk aquifer:

(i) at Baldock specifically and

(ii) from the aquifer as a whole.

2. Elicit plans from Affinity Water with regard to use of AMP7 (2015–2020 Asset Management Plan) money to invest in effective measures to conserve and enhance the Ivel specifically and other local chalk streams generally.

3. Seek a pledge from Affinity Water that it will take the steps necessary to ensure that a specified minimum water flow is maintained in the upper Ivel throughout the year.

4. Seek assurance from the Environment Agency that it will continue to monitor the impact of water abstraction from the aquifer on our local environment and take appropriate action, including consideration of withdrawal of abstraction licences, where Affinity Water allows its activities to harm the environment.

5. Support and work with local interest groups, including the RevIvel Association in Radwell.

6. Support the establishment of an integrated, overarching partnership to enable all relevant agencies and organisations to collaborate with the aim of protecting the chalk streams of the aquifer in its entirety.

7. Lobby our constituency MPs for active support in all of the above.

Audio recording – 26 minutes 13 seconds

The following motion had been submitted, due notice of which had been given in accordance with Standing Order 4.8.12:

A River Ivel

It was proposed by Councillor Tom Tyson, seconded by Councillor Paul Clark that:

This Council expresses its concern about the perilous state of the upper reaches of the

River Ivel and other local chalk streams, including the Rivers Purwell and Hiz and St

Ippolyts Brook.

Council notes that the River Ivel has been continuously dry in an area extending from the

Ivel Springs Local Nature Reserve downstream to Radwell for a period of well over a

year.

Council further notes that there has been no flow in the upper Ivel during half the months

of the previous four years.

The River Ivel is one of the rare and ecologically important chalk streams of the Chiltern

Chalk Aquifer. According to the Ivel Springs Greenspace Action Plan for 2010–2015,

“Chalk rivers are extremely rare and included in the Herts Biodiversity Action Plan. The

river and its wetlands are important habitats for a wide range of species”. This is a

resource we should cherish and protect. Instead, the watercourses are dry, the fish are

dead and other associated wildlife is gone.

Council is therefore determined to ensure that a healthy year-round water flow be

restored and maintained in the upper reaches of the river from the area known as Ivel

Springs down to Radwell Lake and beyond.

Furthermore, Council recognises that the disaster of the Ivel is not an isolated instance

among the chalk streams of the Chiltern Chalk Aquifer: many others are suffering

dangerously low levels and consequent environmental harm.

Council therefore undertakes to implement the following actions:

1. Elicit information from Affinity Water regarding their plans for reducing abstraction rates from the chalk aquifer:

(i) at Baldock specifically and

(ii) from the aquifer as a whole.

2. Elicit plans from Affinity Water with regard to use of AMP7 (2015–2020 Asset Management Plan) money to invest in effective measures to conserve and enhance the Ivel specifically and other local chalk streams generally.

3. Seek a pledge from Affinity Water that it will take the steps necessary to ensure that a specified minimum water flow is maintained in the upper Ivel throughout the year.

4. Seek assurance from the Environment Agency that it will monitor the impact of water abstraction from the aquifer on our local environment and take appropriate action where Affinity Water allows its activities to harm the environment.

5. Support and work with local interest groups, including the RevIvel Association in Radwell.

6. Support the establishment of an integrated, overarching partnership to enable all relevant agencies and organisations to collaborate with the aim of protecting the chalk streams of the aquifer in its entirety.

7. Lobby our constituency MPs for active support in all of the above.

The following Members took part in the debate:

· Councillor David Levett;

· Councillor Val Bryant;

· Councillor Elizabeth Dennis-Harburg;

· Councillor Steve Jarvis;

· Councillor David Barnard;

· Councillor Michael Muir;

· Councillor Ian Mantle;

· Councillor Richard Thake;

· Councillor Claire Strong;

· Councillor Michael Weeks.

It was proposed by Councillor Val Bryant that additional wording be added to Section 6 of the motion to read:

“To acknowledge the need for the above to be combined, an active policy for water conservation.”

That additional wording be added to Section 7 of the motion to read:

“With the intention of introducing or strengthening policies at Government level for water conservation.”

Councillor Tyson did not accept the amendments as they did not refer to water abstraction.

Councillor Tyson proposed that additional wording be added to Section 6 of the motion to read:

“Support the establishment of an integrated, overarching partnership to enable all relevant agencies, Local Authorities and organisations to collaborate with the aim of protecting the chalk streams of the aquifer in its entirety.

It was proposed by Councillor Claire Strong that Section 4 of the motion be amended to read:

“Seek assurance from the Environment Agency that it will continue to monitor the impact of water abstraction from the aquifer on our local environment and take appropriate action, including consideration of withdrawing abstraction licences, where Affinity Water allows its activities to harm the environment.”

Councillors Tom Tyson and Paul Clark accepted the amendment.

Following debate it was: